How executives should talk about failure

The Thoughtful Executive is a weekly executive-level newsletter on thought leadership, content marketing, and strategic messaging for the C-suite. Delivered every Wednesday.

Most executive “failure” stories are useless. They’re either vague (“we learned a lot”), over-sanitized (“unexpected headwinds”), or emotional dumps with no real takeaway.

Done well, though, a failure story is one of the most powerful tools an executive has for building trust outside the company and aligning how people think inside it.

The difference is all in how you tell it.

Most of what passes for talking about failure falls into three buckets.

You’ve seen these: “We made some mistakes and learned a lot along the way.”

No specific decision, no stakes, no change. It feels safe, but it doesn’t help anyone understand what actually happened or what will be different next time.

Here, everything is about “unexpected headwinds,” “macro uncertainty,” and “market shifts no one could have predicted.”

The company sounds like a victim of the weather, not an actor that chose a path and got it wrong. It protects the brand in the short term but robs the story of any useful signal.

On the other extreme, you get long, confessional posts that detail every emotion but never land on clear lessons. They might be honest, but they don’t give employees, customers, or investors anything concrete to work with. It’s cathartic, but not leadership.

A useful failure story does something different. It names what happened, what people believed, who it affected, and what will change now.

You don’t need a 3,000-word memoir every time something goes wrong. You need four clear beats that anyone in your company can repeat.

Name the specific bet, launch, or decision that didn’t work.

One thing, clearly described: “We launched X,” “We pivoted Y,” “We bet on Z.”

Not “a series of challenges over several quarters.”

Spell out the assumption behind the decision.

“We believed this is what our best customers wanted.”

“We assumed we could win on speed even if the product lagged in features.”

This is the part most failure stories skip, and it’s the most valuable.

Be concrete about impact: revenue, customers, team, reputation. Enough to make it real, but not enough to turn it into a crisis play-by-play.

“The result was delayed value for customers, churn in segment X, and six months of work for teams A and B.”

Close with what will now be different: process, metrics, who is in the room, what you will not do again.

“This is the gate we’re adding.”
“These are the signals we watch now.”
“This is the kind of bet we won’t make again.”

When an executive hits all four beats, failure stops being a fuzzy memory and becomes a reusable asset.

Here’s how this looks when real leaders do it well.

In early 2025, a senior product leader wrote about “700 days of failure” before becoming CEO of a multibillion‑dollar company. The piece lives in that uncomfortable space between career story and public postmortem.

She doesn’t hide behind macro conditions. She names specific behaviors: controlling the roadmap, shutting out go-to-market partners, ignoring peers, assuming that being the smartest person in the room justified making every call.

The turning point is a blunt conversation where an adviser tells her, plainly, that she is the common denominator.

Mapped to the four beats:

What you can steal:

Use this as a template for behavior-level failure, not just outcome-level failure.
For your own exec, think in terms of: Here’s how I used to lead. Here’s what it cost. Here’s what I do differently now.

In 2026, the founder of a bootstrapped health AI startup wrote a postmortem about shutting the company down after seven years. On paper, the company had patents, paying customers, and clinical impact—and still didn’t make it.

She doesn’t gesture vaguely at “market timing.” She lists specific mistakes: thin customer discovery, the wrong MVP, underpowered sales and marketing, choosing the wrong cofounders, skipping critical integrations.

For each, she adds why she made the mistake—overconfidence in technical elegance, underestimating go-to-market, trying to be CEO, CTO, and head of sales at the same time.

Mapped to the four beats:

What you can steal:

This is the “multi‑chapter failure” pattern, perfect for complex bets that fail for several reasons at once. You can use the same structure: list the mistakes, then add a column for “why we made them” and “what we’ll do differently.”

In 2025, a founder wrote a postmortem on raising a couple of million dollars for a database gateway product that enterprises loved to test, but never fully adopted. On the surface, there was interest, pilots, and logos. But underneath, there was a growth ceiling they couldn’t crack.

He walks through “pilot purgatory,” early signals they misread as validation, and the slow realization that the product lived in the wrong part of the stack. He calls failure a “cursed word,” then proceeds to unpack exactly what went wrong in market selection and sales motion, rather than blaming the customers.

Mapped to the four beats:

What you can steal:

For B2B teams, this is a clean template for talking about launches that “sort of worked” but never broke out. Frame your own exec’s failed bets in similar terms: pilots, features, or campaigns that lived forever in the “almost” bucket, and what you’ve changed because of that.

From the outside, these look like brave, honest pieces of content. Inside a company, they can function as infrastructure.

A well‑structured failure story becomes a shared reference point.

Your job isn’t to go looking for failure. Your job is to be ready with a clear structure when there’s a story that should be told.

Sometimes that’s a non‑urgent, older bet that still has real lessons for the market. Other times, it’s a recent miss that your company will be talking about for a while anyway.
In both cases, having a game plan beats improvising under pressure.

Think of these as prompts you pull out once you and your exec already agree there’s a failure that would add value if you shared it—internally, externally, or both.

These questions naturally pull out the four beats: event, belief, cost, change. You don’t have to work through them in a single meeting, and you don’t need to apply them to every bump in the road. They’re there so that when something meaningful does go wrong, you have a responsible way to turn it into a story that actually helps people.

Once you’ve shaped it, you can decide how far to take it:

Success stories tell people what you hoped would happen. Failure stories, done well, show people how you actually think when it matters.

Thought leadership and executive comms are not just about broadcasting big ideas.
They’re the clearest way to make a company’s real beliefs—and its hard‑won lessons—visible to everyone who needs them.

How should executives handle fear of failure when speaking publicly?
Executives don’t need to share every misstep on LinkedIn or a podcast to show great leadership. Instead, they should pick a small number of past mistakes that now have clear lessons learned and talk through what changed in their decision-making and problem-solving afterward. That lowers the fear of failure while still giving their audience valuable lessons they can apply in similar situations.

What’s a good “first place” to start if our company hasn’t talked about failure before?
Start with a non-urgent story – not the biggest failure in company history, but a past startup bet, product launch, or initiative that the company has clearly recovered from. Focus on what the team learned, how they bounced back, and how that shaped future decision-making for successful leaders on your team.

How can failure stories help with leadership development and team building?
When great leaders walk through a failure with their team members – what they believed, what went wrong, and how they adjusted – it becomes a leadership development tool. It normalizes taking risks, improves teamwork, and gives people a concrete pattern for how to respond to public failures or internal misses without blame.

Should entrepreneurs and startup leaders share their biggest failure in detail?
Entrepreneurs don’t have to turn every scar into content, but talking through one or two well-chosen failures can be powerful. The key is to show how they bounced back – the specific problem-solving steps, the changes in team building and teamwork, and how those valuable lessons now guide their decision-making in similar situations.

How do failure stories support teams beyond the executive?
A well-structured failure story gives team members a language for talking about risk and past mistakes without getting stuck in shame. It gives successful leaders, not just the CEO, a template for clear communication in tough moments and helps everyone stay aligned when they face similar situations again.

Each week, we share executive-level guidance on thought leadership, strategic content, and building trust with decision-makers. Subscribe to receive the newsletter every Wednesday.

Johnathan Silver helps executives turn judgment and experience into effective thought leadership. Through The Thoughtful Executive, he works with senior leaders and marketing teams to build thought leadership programs, sharpen executive voice, and create content that earns trust over time. His work sits at the intersection of leadership communication, content strategy, and executive decision-making.